Repair or Replace? How to Decide on a Faulty Commercial Vacuum or Floor Machine

Repair or Replace? How to Decide on a Faulty Commercial Vacuum or Floor Machine

When commercial vacuums or floor cleaning machines break down, it can be a dilemma to decide whether to pay for repairs or invest in replacements. The decision involves more than a quick look at the repair bill: you need to weigh the machine’s age and reliability, parts availability, and the cost of downtime.

These factors all matter, so let us help you make an informed decision.

The Age and Cost Rule of Thumb (Repair Cost vs Replacement Cost)

A useful starting point could be comparing a repair quote with the cost of a replacement cleaning machine.

An ageing machine with repeating faults may be more costly to maintain than a newer model that doesn’t go wrong. A fairly new machine that has a straightforward problem may well be worth repairing, especially if aside from the fault it performs well.

You should consider the total cost of ownership: purchase price + repair costs + servicing and maintenance + consumables + expected remaining lifespan.

Unfortunately, there is no simple equation for calculating whether replacement is the most worthwhile option. The condition and future reliability of the machine are also important. We recommend seeking a detailed diagnosis of any faults before committing to repair or replacement.

Which Parts are Cheap to Fix and Which are not

Some machine faults involve relatively simple parts that can be replaced safely and easily, while others are more complex and may signal a need for more costly replacement.

Typically Inexpensive Parts More Complex Parts
Hose (easily damaged) Motors
Bags and filters (consumable) Printed Circuit Boards (PCBs) (these control electrical functions of the machine)
Switches and power cords (appropriate to be replaced by electrical specialist) —

The price of individual components isn’t the only factor for consideration. Labour, availability and the cause of the fault are also important in the final quoted price.

Electrical repairs should be handled by appropriately qualified specialists rather than handled as improvised DIY fixes.

Downtime Cost for a Cleaning Contractor

A broken machine affects more than just your repair budget. It may lead to additional staff time spent cleaning manually, which has knock-on effects such as re-arranging subsequent work or hiring temporary replacements.

A machine failure may cause two workers to spend an extra hour on a task, meaning your business loses two labour hours. And this is before factoring in other disruption or costs.

When weighing up the costs of repair or replacement, you must remember the cost of lost productivity, missed deadlines and temporary equipment alongside the costs incurred by the machine itself. A prompt repair may be worthwhile even if the invoice looks expensive at the outset.

Brands With Good Parts Availability

An established parts supply can make your cleaning machines much easier to maintain over their working lives. When choosing a brand and model, consider the availability of replacement parts and manufacturer support, as well as the expected lead time for components you are likely to need.

Less expensive machines can become more costly over time if their essential replacement parts are difficult to source.

At Big Clean, we encourage you to check the availability of parts for your existing machines before deciding to replace it.

What a Free Quote or Inspection Involves, and a Hire Machine in the Meantime

A detailed inspection can help to identify the fault with a machine and establish whether it's practical to pursue repair rather than replacement. When requesting a quote, it is sensible to give the make, model, age and maintenance history as well as a description of the issues you’ve experienced with the machine.

A technician may need to physically examine the equipment before confirming a quote for repairs: a detailed description may not be enough.

Temporary hire can be a good way to maintain your cleaning operations while a machine is assessed or repaired. You can fill in a Big Clean rental request form here.